Retaining Your Buy Box Dominance: Top Strategies for Success

Retaining Your Buy Box Dominance: Top Strategies for Success cover

The Buy Box is a crucial aspect of selling on Amazon and winning it can mean the difference between success and failure for a seller. Retaining your Buy Box dominance, however, can be even more challenging.

In this article, we will delve into the strategies for success in retaining the Buy Box and understanding the risks of losing it once you win it. Whether you’re a seasoned seller or just starting out, this guide will provide you with valuable insights and tips to help you maintain your Buy Box dominance.


  • The Buy Box is a critical component of success for sellers on Amazon as it can significantly increase sales and drive traffic to their product listings.
  • To retain Buy Box dominance, sellers must optimize their product listings and enhance the customer experience by focusing on price optimization, inventory management, delivery speed and performance, and excellent customer service.
  • By continuously monitoring the Buy Box and adjusting their offerings, sellers can remain competitive and increase their chances of winning the Buy Box.

Understanding the Buy Box

The Amazon Buy Box is a feature on the platform that allows customers to add a product to their shopping cart with one click. It’s typically displayed on the right-hand side of a product detail page and is the most prominent place for customers to make a purchase.

The Buy Box is awarded to one seller at a time based on a combination of factors which we’ll get into soon. The goal of the Buy Box is to provide customers with the best shopping experience by highlighting the seller who is most likely to provide a seamless and valuable transaction.

For sellers, winning the Buy Box is crucial as it can significantly increase sales and drive traffic to their product listings. Approximately 83% of all Amazon sales occur through the Buy Box, making it the primary source of revenue for many sellers. Winning the Buy Box position can also increase brand visibility and help establish a seller’s reputation, leading to increased customer loyalty and repeat sales.

In short, the Buy Box is a critical component of success for sellers on Amazon, and retaining dominance in the Buy Box is crucial for maintaining a profitable and successful business.

Factors that Influence the Buy Box

There are several factors that Amazon considers when determining which seller will win the Buy Box. These include:

  1. Price: Amazon rewards sellers who offer competitive prices by giving them the Buy Box.
  2. Availability: A product must be in stock and available for immediate shipment to win the Buy Box.
  3. Delivery speed: Amazon values fast delivery and gives priority to sellers who can get products to customers quickly.
  4. Seller ratings: Amazon takes into account the feedback from customers regarding their experience with a particular seller. Sellers with high ratings are more likely to win the Buy Box.
  5. Fulfillment method: Amazon gives preference to sellers who use its fulfillment service, Fulfillment by Amazon (FBA).
  6. Product quality: Amazon values high-quality products and may choose to award the Buy Box to sellers who offer premium products.

By keeping these factors in mind, you can optimize your listings and increase your chances of winning the Buy Box. However, it’s important to note that Amazon’s algorithm is constantly evolving, and what works today may not work tomorrow.

As a result, sellers must continuously monitor and adjust their listings to ensure they remain competitive and maintain their Buy Box ownership.

Strategies for Retaining Buy Box Dominance

To retain Buy Box dominance, sellers must adopt a combination of strategies that optimize their product listings and enhance the customer experience.

Price Optimization

There are millions of price changes daily on Amazon and by continuously monitoring and adjusting your own prices in response to market changes and competitor activity, can help you remain competitive and quickly improve your chances of winning the Buy Box.

However, it’s important to strike a balance between price and profitability. Selling at too low of a price can lead to reduced margins, while pricing too high can result in lost sales. As a result, it’s crucial for you to find the optimal price point that maximizes both sales and profits.

For example, you could set your minimum price at 5% above your cost of goods, and then use an automated repricer such as to adjust your prices based on the lowest price offered by your competitors. This way, you can ensure you are never undercutting your own profits while still staying competitive and increasing your chances of winning the Buy Box.

Related: The Ultimate Guide to Repricing on Amazon

Inventory Management

By keeping your products in stock and available for immediate shipment, you can ensure you meet customer demands there and then which proves to Amazon that you are a reliable and consistent seller – this in turn can result in you winning the Buy Box.

Additionally, by monitoring your inventory levels and proactively restocking before running out of stock, you can avoid stockouts and maintain your availability.

Furthermore, utilizing inventory management software such as InventoryLab can provide you with valuable insights into your inventory levels, sales patterns, and demand forecasts, enabling you to make informed decisions and optimize your stock levels.

Delivery Speed & Performance

​Customers expect their purchases to arrive quickly, and Amazon rewards sellers who can deliver products quickly by giving them the coveted Buy Box position. To maintain your Buy Box dominance, you should consider using Amazon’s Prime shipping option or utilize other fast and reliable shipping carriers.

Additionally, monitoring delivery performance and proactively addressing any issues, such as late or damaged deliveries, can help maintain a positive delivery experience for customers and, once again, increase your chances of winning the Buy Box. Simply by consistently delivering products quickly and efficiently, you can establish a reputation for offering valuable and reliable delivery.

Excellent Customer Service

Customers expect a positive and seamless shopping experience, and Amazon rewards sellers who consistently provide outstanding customer service by awarding them the Buy Box. To retain their dominance over the Buy Box, sellers should respond promptly to customer inquiries and complaints, and resolve any issues in a professional and satisfactory manner.

eDesk is an excellent tool that can streamline this process for you and your team, removing the hassle of using separate communication systems by bringing all of your customers’ queries into one manageable place.

Product Quality

Customers expect the products they purchase to meet their expectations and Amazon rewards sellers who consistently offer high-quality products. You want to ensure that you prioritize product quality and continuously improve your product offerings to meet customer demands. This can include using high-quality materials, manufacturing products to exacting standards, and conducting regular quality control checks.

Additionally, seeking out customer feedback and addressing any quality-related issues can help maintain customer satisfaction. This proves to your customers that you value their time and appreciate their custom, as a result, this shows Amazon that you’re a trustworthy and reliable seller.


Customers rely on feedback and reviews from previous buyers to inform their purchasing decisions. The Amazon Buy Box algorithm not only takes positive and negative reviews into account, but it also looks at the number of reviews received.

Without them, your account’s visibility can drop significantly. So follow up with customers to request reviews, using a feedback tool to automate the process.

Amazon’s algorithm has a rating system of 0-100. The higher your rating, the better chance you stand of winning the Buy Box.

This algorithm looks at feedback from the past 30, 90 and 365 days, but recent feedback is most important. These stats can be seen in your Seller Account.

Can You Lose the Buy Box Once You Win it?

The Buy Box is dynamic and awarded based on a variety of factors, as discussed. As a result, other sellers who are competing for the Buy Box can (depending on their seller metrics) potentially overtake a seller’s position.

Changes in Amazon’s policies and algorithms can also impact a seller’s chances of winning the Buy Box.

To minimize the risk of losing the Buy Box, you should continuously monitor your performance and adapt your strategies as needed to meet the evolving criteria set above.

How to Win Back the Buy Box If You Lose It

Losing the Buy Box position can be quite demoralizing as it can make a significant impact on your sales and overall profits. However, this shouldn’t hold you back. It’s time to stand back up again and dust yourself off.

Amazon is a constantly changing environment however customer centricity is at the company’s core belief. With this in mind, you need to focus on how you can make your business more customer-centric. The more emphasis you put on the customer and improve their shopping experience, the greater the chance of winning the Buy Box.

Perform analysis on your:

  • Feedback rating – what is your current rating out of 100?
  • Stock levels – do you have stock available to fulfill all current orders?
  • Shipping times – are you processing & sending orders out quickly?
  • Order defect rate – is it currently below 1%?
  • Customer response time – are you responding to customers within 24 hours?
  • Product pricing – are you optimizing your products prices automatically?

Could these metrics be improved? What is it you can do that will give you the edge over the competition?

Final Thoughts

In conclusion, retaining the Amazon Buy Box is essential for sellers to achieve ongoing success.

A number of factors influence who wins the Buy Box but it’s the seller who puts the customer first and offers the best value, not only in terms of price but overall experience will be one of the chosen to hold the highly coveted position.

As a seller, you must continuously monitor and optimize these factors discussed to ensure that you meet customer expectations and remain competitive.

By implementing effective strategies, such as price optimization, inventory management, providing excellent customer service, and maintaining high product quality, you can minimize the risk of losing the Buy Box and increase your chances of long-term success on Amazon.

repricer free trial buy box cta

Ronan White
Ronan White
SEO and content marketing executive at Repricer. Loves cycling, cinema, a few beers and all things outdoors.
Share this article
Dedicated solution to help online retailers grow faster, and sell more!


Automatically reprice on Amazon to stay competitive 24/7. Win the Buy Box and multiply your earnings. Learn more...

Free 14 Day Trial

No credit card required

Most Popular
Table of Contents

More to explore

See our Privacy Notice for details as to how we use your personal data and your rights.